If your bathtub is looking worn, stained, or outdated, you might be weighing two options: refinishing or full replacement. Both can give you a fresh, like-new bathroom — but they differ dramatically in cost, timeline, and disruption to your home.
The Cost Difference
Full bathtub replacement typically runs $3,000–$7,000 when you factor in the new tub, plumbing modifications, tile work, and labor. For higher-end tubs or complex plumbing situations, costs can climb even higher.
Bathtub refinishing, on the other hand, typically costs $689–$900 — a savings of 70–90%. The process restores your existing tub to a factory-smooth finish without any demolition or plumbing work.
Timeline and Disruption
Replacement projects usually take 3–5 days minimum, and your bathroom is completely unusable during that time. You may also discover hidden issues like water damage or outdated plumbing once demolition begins.
Refinishing is completed in a single day, and your tub is ready to use within 24 hours. No demolition, no dust, no surprises.
When to Choose Refinishing
Refinishing is the right choice when:
- Your tub is structurally sound but cosmetically worn
- You want to change the color of your tub
- You have chips, cracks, stains, or surface etching
- You're working within a budget
- You need a fast turnaround
When Replacement Makes Sense
Consider replacement when:
- The tub has severe structural damage (cracked through)
- You want to change the size, shape, or style of tub entirely
- Plumbing needs to be reconfigured
Our Recommendation
For most homeowners, refinishing is the smart choice. It delivers beautiful, long-lasting results at a fraction of the cost and time. At Heritage Coatings, every bathtub refinish comes with a 5-year warranty and is ready to use in 24 hours.
Ready to transform your bathtub? Call us at (406) 438-4288 or request a free estimate online.